Table of Cases
This page was last modified on June 5, 2006. There are no plans to update it further.
The Legal Guide includes scope/coverage of legislation, express warranties, implied warranties, privity & products liability, remedies and waivers. Also included are the full text of the legislation, cases (indexed by name, section considered, product, judge & date), law review articles, background law reform reports, top 10 list and table of contents.
This website was created by Karl Dore, the principal architect of the Consumer Product Warranty and Liability Act. It is intended to provide information on the legislation, not to give or offer individual legal advice. For further assistance contact New Brunswick's Consumer Affairs Branch or one of the Rentalsman Offices.
This page was last modified on June 5, 2006.
- By name
- By section of Act applied
- By kind of product
- By judge
- By level of court
- By date
- Cases where party (or parties) not represented by legal counsel
By name
- C & L Transport Ltd v Brine
- Cavanaugh v Brookside Mini Home Park Ltd
- Collier v MacMaster's Auto Sales
- Crabbe v Community Motors Ltd
- Crouse v Moncton Ford
- Gallant v Larry Woods Used Cars Ltd
- Gandy v Robinson
- Gauvin and LeBlanc v Dryden Motors Limited
- Gibson v Whalen
- Gillespie v MacDonald Pontiac Buick GMC Ltd
- Gionet v NB Power
- Godin v Star-Key Ent Ltd
- Greene v DR Sutherland Ltd and Sutherland
- Lagacé v Bison (Restigouche) Ltd
- Lanteigne v Foulem & Blanchard Ltée
- LeBlanc v Brett (Lorne) Chev Olds Ltd
- LeBlanc (P.J.) v. Oland Breweries Ltd
- MacLean v Hafford Motors Ltd
- Mallet v Brunswick Rent-A-Car ltée
- Mann v Cobra Jeans
- McGouey v Lawson Motors Ltd
- McNeil v Shaw (LE) Limited
- Medjuck & Budovitch Ltd v Young
- Parker v New Brunswick Power Corp
- Peterson v Clark (J) & Son Ltd
- Savin Canada Inc v Wood
- Savoie v Lavoie
- Seller v Daye (Roly) & Sons Ltd
- Sheppard v Jardine Auctioneers Inc
- Silliker v NB Power
- Sirois v Centennial Pontiac Buick GMC Ltd and General Motors of Canada Ltd
- Wall v Dieppe Auto Ltd
- Watt v Maillet
- White v Shea et al
- Witherell v Buchanan Estate
- Wood v Connell Motors
By section of Act applied
(listed in reverse chronological order)
Section 1: "consumer loss"
Section 1 "consumer product"
- Cavanaugh v. Brookside Mini Home Park Ltd.
- Savoie v. Lavoie
- Wood v. Connell Motors
- Gandy v. Robinson
- Medjuck & Budovitch Ltd. v. Young
- Lanteigne v. Foulem & Blanchard Ltée
- Savin Canada Inc. v. Wood
- McNeil v. Shaw (L.E.) Limited
- Crabbe v. Community Motors Ltd.
- Greene v. D.R. Sutherland Ltd. and Sutherland
Section 1 "distributor"
- Duplessis v MacKenney
- Johnson v. Maritime Water Treatment Ltd.
- Witherell v. Buchanan Estate
- VanWart v. MacDonald
- C. & L. Transport Ltd. v. Brine
- Lanteigne v. Foulem & Blanchard Ltée
Section 2
- Duplessis v MacKenney
- Dunham v. Lewis
- Doiron v. Bayside Chrysler Dodge Ltd.
- Witherell v. Buchanan Estate
- Watt v. Maillet
- C. & L. Transport Ltd. v. Brine
- Sirois v. Centennial Pontiac Buick GMC Ltd. and General Motors of Canada Ltd.
Section 4
- MacLean v. Hafford Motors Ltd.
- Doiron v. Bayside Chrysler Dodge Ltd.
- Julien v. General Motors of Canada Ltd.
- Collier v. MacMaster's Auto Sales
- Wall v. Dieppe Auto Ltd.
- Gillespie v. MacDonald Pontiac Buick GMC Ltd. (Court of Appeal)
- LeBlanc v. Brett (Lorne) Chev Olds Ltd.
- McNeil v. Shaw (L.E.) Limited
- Crabbe v. Community Motors Ltd.
- McGouey v. Lawson Motors Ltd.
- Audet v. Central Motors Ltd.
- Gauvin and LeBlanc v. Dryden Motors Limited
Section 5
- Doiron v. Bayside Chrysler Dodge Ltd.
- Gillespie v. MacDonald Pontiac Buick GMC Ltd. (Court of Appeal)
- McGouey v. Lawson Motors Ltd.
Section 7
Section 10
- Lagacé v. Bison (Restigouche) Ltd.
- Seller v. Daye (Roly) & Sons Ltd.
- Brideau v. Arseneau
- Sheppard v. Jardine Auctioneers Inc.
- Johnson v. Maritime Water Treatment Ltd.
- Doiron v. Bayside Chrysler Dodge Ltd.
- Peterson v. Clark (J.) & Son Ltd. (Court of Appeal)
- Peterson v. Clark (J.) & Son Ltd. (Trial)
- Gionet v. N.B. Power
- Mann v. Cobra Jeans
- Beaulieu v. Leisure Time Sales
- Silliker v. N.B. Power
- Thériault v. Boutique La Chatelaine ltée
- Medjuck & Budovitch Ltd. v. Young
- Gillespie v. MacDonald Pontiac Buick GMC Ltd. (Court of Appeal)
- McGouey v. Lawson Motors Ltd.
- Gallant v. Larry Woods Used Cars Ltd.
Section 11
- Seller v. Daye (Roly) & Sons Ltd.
- Johnson v. Maritime Water Treatment Ltd.
- Peterson v. Clark (J.) & Son Ltd. (Court of Appeal)
- Peterson v. Clark (J.) & Son Ltd. (Trial)
- Wall v. Dieppe Auto Ltd.
- Lanteigne v. Foulem & Blanchard Ltée
- McNeil v. Shaw (L.E.) Limited
Section 12
- Crouse v Moncton Ford
- Lagacé v. Bison (Restigouche) Ltd.
- Seller v. Daye (Roly) & Sons Ltd.
- Brideau v. Arseneau
- Sheppard v. Jardine Auctioneers Inc.
- Peterson v. Clark (J.) & Son Ltd. (Court of Appeal)
- Peterson v. Clark (J.) & Son Ltd. (Trial)
- Gionet v. N.B. Power
- Mann v. Cobra Jeans
- Parker v. New Brunswick Power Corp. (Trial)
- Witherell v. Buchanan Estate
- VanWart v. MacDonald
- Silliker v. N.B. Power
- Ryan v. Sutherland Equipment
- Alder v. Defazio Autobody Ltd.
- Thériault v. Roy
- McGouey v. Lawson Motors Ltd.
- Gallant v. Larry Woods Used Cars Ltd.
Section 14
- VanWart v. MacDonald
- Beaulieu v. Leisure Time Sales
- Ryan v. Sutherland Equipment
- Sirois v. Centennial Pontiac Buick GMC Ltd. and General Motors of Canada Ltd.
- Medjuck & Budovitch Ltd. v. Young
- White v. Shea et al.
- LeBlanc v. Brett (Lorne) Chev Olds Ltd.
- McGouey v. Lawson Motors Ltd.
- Greene v. D.R. Sutherland Ltd. and Sutherland
- Audet v. Central Motors Ltd.
- Gauvin and LeBlanc v. Dryden Motors Limited
Section 15
- Godin v Star-Key Ent Ltd
- Johnson v. Maritime Water Treatment Ltd.
- Gibson v. Whalen
- Doiron v. Bayside Chrysler Dodge Ltd.
- Parker v. New Brunswick Power Corp. (Court of Appeal)
- Parker v. New Brunswick Power Corp. (Trial)
- Mann v. Cobra Jeans
- VanWart v. MacDonald
- Alder v. Defazio Autobody Ltd.
- Julien v. General Motors of Canada Ltd.
- Collier v. MacMaster's Auto Sales
- Gandy v. Robinson
- Sirois v. Centennial Pontiac Buick GMC Ltd. and General Motors of Canada Ltd.
- White v. Shea et al.
- Lanteigne v. Foulem & Blanchard Ltée
- McGouey v. Lawson Motors Ltd.
Section 16
- Ryan v Milligan's Cycle Works
- Crouse v Moncton Ford
- VanWart v. MacDonald
- Beaulieu v. Leisure Time Sales
- Ryan v. Sutherland Equipment
- Collier v. MacMaster's Auto Sales
- Savoie v. Lavoie
- Thériault v. Roy
- Gandy v. Robinson
- Sirois v. Centennial Pontiac Buick GMC Ltd. and General Motors of Canada Ltd.
- Medjuck & Budovitch Ltd. v. Young
- Gillespie v. MacDonald Pontiac Buick GMC Ltd. (Court of Appeal)
- White v. Shea et al.
- LeBlanc v. Brett (Lorne) Chev Olds Ltd.
- McGouey v. Lawson Motors Ltd.
- Audet v. Central Motors Ltd.
- Gauvin and LeBlanc v. Dryden Motors Limited
Section 17
- Johnson v. Maritime Water Treatment Ltd.
- Gibson v. Whalen
- VanWart v. MacDonald
- Beaulieu v. Leisure Time Sales
- Ryan v. Sutherland Equipment
- Collier v. MacMaster's Auto Sales
- Gandy v. Robinson
- Gillespie v. MacDonald Pontiac Buick GMC Ltd. (Court of Appeal)
- LeBlanc v. Brett (Lorne) Chev Olds Ltd.
- McGouey v. Lawson Motors Ltd.
- Audet v. Central Motors Ltd.
- Gauvin and LeBlanc v. Dryden Motors Limited
Section 18
Section 19
- VanWart v. MacDonald
- Gillespie v. MacDonald Pontiac Buick GMC Ltd. (Court of Appeal)
- LeBlanc v. Brett (Lorne) Chev Olds Ltd.
- McGouey v. Lawson Motors Ltd.
- Gauvin and LeBlanc v. Dryden Motors Limited
Section 22
Section 23
Section 25
Section 26
Section 27
Section 28
- Crouse v Moncton Ford
- Gauvin and LeBlanc v. Dryden Motors Limited
By kind of product
(listed in reverse chronological order)
Antenna (satellite dish)
Automobiles
New
Used
-
- Duplessis v MacKenney
- Crouse v Moncton Ford
- Dunham v. Lewis
- Brideau v. Arseneau
- MacLean v. Hafford Motors Ltd.
- Sheppard v. Jardine Auctioneers Inc.
- Gibson v. Whalen
- Peterson v. Clark (J.) & Son Ltd. (Court of Appeal)
- Peterson v. Clark (J.) & Son Ltd. (Trial)
- Witherell v. Buchanan Estate
- Watt v. Maillet
- VanWart v. MacDonald
- Collier v. MacMaster's Auto Sales
- Thériault v. Roy
- Wall v. Dieppe Auto Ltd.
- Gillespie v. MacDonald Pontiac Buick GMC Ltd. (Court of Appeal)
- McGouey v. Lawson Motors Ltd.
- Gallant v. Larry Woods Used Cars Ltd.
- Audet v. Central Motors Ltd.
- Gauvin and LeBlanc v. Dryden Motors Limited
Automobile -- Ball joints
Automobile -- Exhaust system
Automobile -- Paint job
Cement (masonry cement)
Clothing
Jeans
Leather jacket
Curtains, Drapes and Accessories (custom made)
Dog
Heat pump (with duct work and related materials and services)
Horse
Hot water heater
Mini home
Motorcycle
Photocopier
Snowmobile -- Used
Tractor -- Used
Truck -- New
Truck -- Used
Van
Well water pump
By judge
(listed in reverse chronological order)
Angers
Ayles
Barry
Bastarache
Creaghan (Paul S.)
- Ryan v Milligan's Cycle Works
- Beaulieu v. Leisure Time Sales
- Wall v. Dieppe Auto Ltd.
- Lanteigne v. Foulem & Blanchard Ltée
Creaghan (W.L.M.)
Daigle
Deschênes
Dickson
- Gillespie v. MacDonald Pontiac Buick GMC Ltd. (Trial)
- McNeil v. Shaw (L.E.) Limited
- Crabbe v. Community Motors Ltd.
- Gallant v. Larry Woods Used Cars Ltd.
Drapeau
Garnett
Glennie
Grant
Guerette
Higgins
Hoyt
Jones
Landry
Larlee
Léger (J.A. Réginald)
McIntyre
McLellan
- Godin v Star-Key Ent Ltd
- VanWart v. MacDonald
- Ryan v. Sutherland Equipment
- Alder v. Defazio Autobody Ltd.
- Julien v. General Motors of Canada Ltd.
- Collier v. MacMaster's Auto Sales
- Savoie v. Lavoie
- Wood v. Connell Motors
- Thériault v. Roy
- Thériault v. Boutique La Chatelaine ltée
- Gandy v. Robinson
Meldrum
Miller
Rice
- Peterson v. Clark (J.) & Son Ltd.
- Parker v. New Brunswick Power Corp.
- Gillespie v. MacDonald Pontiac Buick GMC Ltd.
Russell
Ryan (Henry)
Ryan (Patrick)
- Parker v. New Brunswick Power Corp.
- Witherell v. Buchanan Estate
- Sirois v. Centennial Pontiac Buick GMC Ltd. and General Motors of Canada Ltd.
Stevenson
Tuck
Turnbull (Wallace)
Young
By level of court
(listed in reverse chronological order)
All are trial decisions except the following are by the Court of Appeal:
- Crouse v Moncton Ford
- Peterson v. Clark (J.) & Son Ltd.
- Parker v. New Brunswick Power Corp.
- Witherell v. Buchanan Estate
- Sirois v. Centennial Pontiac Buick GMC Ltd. and General Motors of Canada Ltd.
- Gillespie v. MacDonald Pontiac Buick GMC Ltd. (Court of Appeal)
By date
(listed in reverse chronological order)
2006
2005
2004
2003
2002
2001
2000
1999
1998
1997
1996
- Parker v. New Brunswick Power Corp. (Court of Appeal)
- Mann v. Cobra Jeans
- Parker v. New Brunswick Power Corp. (Trial)
1995
1994
1993
1992
1991
- Julien v. General Motors of Canada Ltd.
- Collier v. MacMaster's Auto Sales
- Cavanaugh v. Brookside Mini Home Park Ltd.
- Savoie v. Lavoie
- Wood v. Connell Motors
1990
- Thériault v. Roy
- Thériault v. Boutique La Chatelaine ltée
- Gandy v. Robinson
- Wall v. Dieppe Auto Ltd.
1988
- C. & L. Transport Ltd. v. Brine
- Sirois v. Centennial Pontiac Buick GMC Ltd. and General Motors of Canada Ltd.
- Medjuck & Budovitch Ltd. v. Young
1986
- Lanteigne v. Foulem & Blanchard Ltée
- Gillespie v. MacDonald Pontiac Buick GMC Ltd. (Court of Appeal)
- White v. Shea et al.
- Savin Canada Inc. v. Wood
- LeBlanc v. Brett (Lorne) Chev Olds Ltd.
1984
1982
- Crabbe v. Community Motors Ltd.
- McGouey v. Lawson Motors Ltd.
- Greene v. D.R. Sutherland Ltd. and Sutherland
- Gallant v. Larry Woods Used Cars Ltd.
1981
Cases where party (or parties) not represented by legal counsel
- Ryan v Milligan's Cycle Works
- Dunham v. Lewis
- Lagacé v. Bison (Restigouche) Ltd.
- Seller v. Daye (Roly) & Sons Ltd.
- Brideau v. Arseneau
- Sheppard v. Jardine Auctioneers Inc.
- Gibson v. Whalen
- Doiron v. Bayside Chrysler Dodge Ltd.
- Gionet v. N.B. Power
- Mann v. Cobra Jeans
- Witherell v. Buchanan Estate
- Beaulieu v. Leisure Time Sales
- Ryan v. Sutherland Equipment
- Alder v. Defazio Autobody Ltd.
- Julien v. General Motors of Canada Ltd.
- Savoie v. Lavoie
- Thériault v. Roy
- Thériault v. Boutique La Chatelaine ltée
- Gandy v. Robinson